Skip to content

Finding home and harmony: The first preacher I ever heard

April 3, 2014

Part 3

My posts this week have centered on my faith journey (Part 2) and connections as a Eastern Mennonite College (Part 1) student. The president of EMC at the time (now EMU) was Myron Augsburger, and my personal history with him goes back to my very first days as an infant. He was the first preacher I ever heard the winter I was born in Sarasota, Florida.


My family the winter I was born in Florida: Linda (Pert), front left, Nancy, right, Mom, me and Dad. Our brother Terry would join us four years later who is the only one of us who now lives in Florida. But we all have that sand in our shoes.

My parents had a long love affair with Florida which began on their honeymoon. Mom bargained hard for a honeymoon to the romantic, semi-tropical state that she had only heard about, a perfect place to escape to if your wedding was, like theirs, in the dead of winter in northern Indiana.

They almost didn’t make it because of budget and car breakdowns, but they soldiered on at least in part because “Your daddy promised he would take me to Florida.” They definitely ended up with sand in their shoes and went back to try farming (like many other northern Mennonites) there for about six months in 1951-1952 the winter I was born. They also spent time living in northern Florida for eight years, and wintered in Sarasota for four-five months in their later years, roughly 1992-2002. Altogether roughly 12 years in the Sunshine state.

P1050357Almost-newlywed Myron and Esther Augsburger in front of Tuttle Avenue Mennonite Church, Sarasota, Fla, winter of 1951-1952. From my parents’ photo collection.

Myron was a budding evangelist who at the age of 23, with his bride Esther, was invited to move to Florida to pastor Tuttle Avenue Mennonite Church—a church plant associated with Virginia Conference. It had only 40 persons in May 1951; by Jan. 1952 (the winter I lived there as an infant), the attendance was around 500 (of course winter was and is high tourist season in Sarasota). In Roots & Branches: A Narrative History of the Amish and Mennonites in Southeast US, 1892-1992, (Cascadia Press, 2010) Martin Lehman describes Myron as “an eloquent speaker. He had a gift for evangelism, and his preaching resonated with Mennonites and non-Mennonites alike.” Martin points out that “some 200 [attenders] were of non-Mennonite background.” The whole history and book is rather complex and doesn’t shy from the conflicts which played out.

Augsburger left Tuttle Avenue in July 1953 to become campus pastor at EMC and to continue his schooling (although he spent another period of time pastoring in Florida). But Mom and Dad so much loved having him for their preacher, that all through my childhood, I often heard my Dad say, “I would sure love it if one of my children would go to Eastern Mennonite where Myron Augsburger is.”

That is NOT why I went to EMU but now I wonder if kids ever lean unconsciously towards paths their parents “wish” for?

Many years later I was asked to write an article for the EMU alumni magazine Crossroads when Myron’s long time assistant Peggy Shenk (indeed she served as assistant for three of EMU’s presidents) retired. Peggy recalled her and her husband’s (Michael) long friendship with Esther and Myron, and how as young women dating Michael and Myron they confided to each other that they hoped “the Lord wouldn’t return [to earth] until they got married.” I also enjoyed the opportunity to work with Myron doing “developmental editing” on one of his many books, The Resurrection Life, (Evangel Press) published in 2005 where I mainly broke up his trademark paragraph-long sentences to more manageable chunks. And yes, I got a little pleasure out of editing my former college president’s work. I also had the fun of interviewing both of them in their home about an assignment in India and got to know more about Esther’s remarkable work in art and its theological connections for her.

Myron was only one of three Augsburger brothers (there were five in all and one sister) who had an impact on my life: Don Augsburger was my pastor and high school principal for a number of years in Goshen, and in fact baptized and instructed me in the faith, and my father worked closely with him as a deacon of North Goshen Mennonite Church. Don’s pastoral gifts of tending a congregation, writing and memorizing poetry, and the ability to listen well and between the lines make him also stand out in my spiritual journey. Their brother David, whose creativity and booming bass voice (both singing and speaking on the long running Mennonite Hour radio program) contributed to the success of Mennonite Broadcasts Inc. for a period from about 1966  to 1975 (he left right before I joined staff in 1975). David was still a guiding force as we contracted with him to write and record various Choice radio series he birthed (one series on Living More with Less re-released as recently as 2011). For one series, I served as ghostwriter and Dave said he got a kick out of reading the material because I “out-Augsburgerized David Augsburger” or something like that–had made it sound so much like his writing.

So this Indiana Mennonite farm girl, whose Midwestern roots went so deep she somehow harbored hopes for many years of someday moving back “home,” ended up with even stronger connections to Mennonites of the southeastern U.S., especially Virginia (through my work for the Mennonite church) and Florida. Along with, yes, what shall we say, longtime formal membership in the Presbyterian Church and awesome local congregation, Trinity, and my husband’s deeply rooted Virginia family? Yes, it’s complicated. It has also led to my lifelong search finding harmony among these various threads.

I remember when I first realized I had a new home in Virginia setting: as my colleagues and acquaintances were aging and moving on, I went to funeral or memorial services and looked around and realized that I likely knew more people sitting in those pews than if you suddenly plunked me back in my home Indiana congregation. These were my people. I knew them much longer than my relatively short 17 years in Indiana. And Presbyterians have also become my people: my pastor Ann Held (the longest preacher I’ve ever had, almost 24 years) can play a pretty good “Presbyterian Game,” always striving to connect people. Her special gift.

TrinitysThreePastorsAnn Reed Held, center, flanked by Trinity’s other two pastors, Dan Grandstaff, left, and Don Allen, right, all of whom have been my “Presbyterian pastors.”

Truly, any place can become home when you put down roots. But like the song says, “This world is not my home, I’m just a passin’ through.”

P1050359My mother, Bertha, holding infant me in the trailer park where they lived in Florida. 


How have you put down roots? How much does your church family play a role?


If you love that great Mennonite Hour a cappella music, here’s a link to a bunch of YouTube videos featuring the music (nevermind the visuals, just listen to the music.)


And for my tribute to the wonderful new Presbyterian hymnal, Glory to God (designed by a Mennonite, so there), check here.


And when I get homesick for Sarasota, Fla. and Amish & Mennonite filled-Pinecraft, I go here.



From → Faith, Family Life

  1. Caro - Claire Wiles permalink

    My mother, Bertha, holding infant me in the trailer park where they lived in Florida.
    How have you put down roots? How much does your church family play a role?

    Hi Melodie
    As always I enjoyed your message today and it got me thinking of my own life although not as interesting as the traveling you have done in your life.
    From the time of my birth though to my lat teens, I lived in Toronto Ontario Canada and attended a church there .
    My family were not regular church goers but I attended regularly and went to a Bible class led by a wonderful lady who molded my life and who I kept in touch with until she passed away at a very elderly age.
    After my husband and I got married we were very active and were charter members in a brand new church in our suburban community.
    We had a great church family there and many were young couple raising children as we were.
    We were sad to say goodbye to them in 1977 when we moved to a rural Ontario community where we lived in the country on 10 acres there for the next 37 years.
    We were very much involved in the Baptist church there and were a very close knot church family. The closeness was bright home when in 2007 my husband developed esophageal cancer and was hospitalized in a Toronto hospital for surgery and had severe complications .
    We nearly lost him at that time.
    It was a good 1-2 hours away from our home (depending on the traffic) and as I was not driving at that time, a team of the church family saw to it that I was picked up every day and driven there and someone else drove me home again at night.
    As he was very sick for over a year and half , many people helped us out so many different ways during that time.
    It was a very humbling experience to be on the receiving end but as our son told me ,
    “Mom , you and dad have always been there to help others, expecting nothing in return and now it is someone else’s turn and you must just say thank you and accept is graciously… Not always easy to do!
    Thankfully my husband recovered and a little over two and a half years ago we made the decision to sell our house of over 37years and we moved to Orillia Ontario , which is about an hour and half from where we had lived.
    That was not easy to leave all our church family , but we still try to get back from time to time and we are now getting involved in a new church home and are once again making some wonderful new friends.
    The church will always be the starting place to look for friends.

  2. Moving, while hard sometimes, does have a way of keeping life and relationships fresh–and keep us growing and changing. Thanks for sharing your story too–it is wonderful that your church helped so much during your time of need. 🙂

    • Caro-Claire Wiles permalink

      Yes. We have much to be thankful for.
      Lamentations 3:22-23 New International Version (NIV)

      22 Because of the Lord’s great love we are not consumed,
      for his compassions never fail.
      23 They are new every morning;
      great is your faithfulness.
      The move itself was pretty heavy and we still have many boxes to unpack !
      However we live close to our daughter and her family and also to one of married grandughters who has two of our great grandsons.
      We get to see them often and this is a blessing too!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Jennifer Murch

Art is the only way to run away without leaving home. -Twyla Tharp

Trisha Faye

Cherishing the Past while Celebrating the Present


To walk or tramp about; to gad, wander. < Old French - trapasser (to trespass).

Tuesdays with Laurie

"Whatever you are not changing, you are choosing." —Laurie Buchanan

Hickory Hill Farm

Blueberries, grapes, vegetables, and more

The Centrality and Supremacy of Jesus Christ

The Website & Blog of David D. Flowers

Cynthia's Communique

Navigating careers, the media and life

the practical mystic

spiritual adventures in the real world

Osheta Moore

Shalom in the City

Shirley Hershey Showalter

writing and reading memoir

Mennonite Girls Can Cook

Harmony, grace and wisdom for family living.

mama congo

Harmony, grace and wisdom for family living.


Harmony, grace and wisdom for family living.

Roadkill Crossing

Writing generated from the rural life

%d bloggers like this: