Skip to content

My elusive search for a great broccoli soup recipe

May 3, 2014

BrocSoup2Last week I hinted that when I tasted a tiny sample of the cheesy white sauce for the scalloped potatoes I was making, I was near ecstasy. The elusive perfect recipe for broccoli-cheese soup that had eluded me for so long was in my sampling spoon.

Why had it taken me so long?

Okay, it is not quite as good as Panera’s or say McAlister’s and nobody’s paying me to say that. Love both those soups and here’s one of many online options if you want to try and copy Panera’s recipe (the use of nutmeg here look interesting).

Over the years I have tried at least 3 broccoli-cheese soup recipes and more wild stabs at making a white sauce and then adding broccoli and cheese, etc., which was hit or miss. Edible and quite tasty, but not to die for. And if you didn’t add the milk or cheese at the right time, gross curdling can result. Just sayin’.

Some attempts. Jennifer Murch over at mamas minutia has a recipe for Cheesy Broccoli Potato Soup which looked great and trustworthy (great Mennonite cook but not the plain kind). Her long long list of recipes on her blog is something I only aspire to. I was intrigued that she also noted problems with curdling when she tried hit or miss to come up with a concoction that always worked. You might want to try hers, link above.

I halved Jennifer’s recipe, but for myself, I didn’t see a reason to put in the chicken broth. Sometimes I have chicken broth, sometimes I don’t, and I didn’t want to be hamstrung by that.

Rabbit trail: I had also worked with a recipe from Marjorie Rohrer, an awesome plain Shenandoah Valley Mennonite cook who used to (I don’t know if she still does, but there are cooks like that in almost any plain Mennonite community, if you ask around) open her home to groups for special occasion dinners like wedding anniversaries or rehearsal dinners or retirement parties or even (!) the Sorensen Institute for Political Leadership from UVA, who knew?! See link for a small picture of a dinner in her home. Organizations I have worked for have gone to Marjorie’s (or similar) when we wanted a really really good homecooked meal for a small group of 10-40 ish. I could find online tracks of a cookbook by Marjorie but no place they are actually available anymore: a self published volume (or two?) called Country Home Cooking by Marjorie Rohrer Shank (2006, Spiral). Anyone know where one can be found? (Another Shenandoah Valley blogger shared one recipe to use up an abundance of garden cabbage in season, from Marjorie’s book, which looks interesting too!)

End of that rabbit trail.

Anyway, Marjorie’s recipe for Creamy Broccoli Soup (my copy is handwritten in her hand and photocopied) called for a quart of chopped broccoli, 5 cups milk and 2 ½ cups water and l lb. cubed Velveeta cheese (in addition to others things) so I’m not sure I ever actually made it verbatim but I certainly used it as the basis for adaptations in greatly reduced proportions (with cheddar cheese swapped in for the Velveeta). It called for 1 Tb. chicken base which I’ve never purchased but it must add the same idea as chicken broth.

All of that said, here’s my very own latest successful soup recipe for Cheesy- Broccoli Soup, adapted from the recipe for the cheesy white sauce for Scalloped Potatoes I shared last week.

Cheesy-Broccoli Soup base (you can easily half this recipe)
Based on Thelma Maust’s Scalloped Potato recipe in Mennonite Recipes from the Shenandoah Valley

6 Tablespoons butter
6 Tablespoons flour
1 ½ teaspoons salt
3 cups milk
1 ½ cup sharp cheese, grated
1 cup chopped and cooked broccoli

In saucepan, melt butter. Blend in flour and salt. Gradually heat, stirring in milk. Stir frequently, and keep stirring (!) as sauce thickens and becomes smooth. Add cheese, stirring, (it can scorch easily with all that milk).


Add cooked broccoli pieces. Heat through and serve.


More goodies in the soup: you can also add bits of chopped onion (sautéed or just added in), chopped carrots, cauliflower, potatoes (all of these cooked before you add them), more cheese, different cheeses, crumbled bacon, as desired.



Do you have a really good broccoli soup recipe (share link) of any description? I’d love to hear about more.

What is your most recent pleasant cooking surprise?

For another really great, comprehensive Mennonite recipe book from the Shenandoah Valley, don’t forget about Mennonite Country-Style Recipes and Kitchen Secrets: The Prize Collection of a Shenandoah Valley Cook, by Esther H. Shank, available here.

Mennonite Country-Style Recipes and Kitchen Secrets

  1. Caro - Claire Wiles permalink

    Your recipes sound and look tantalizingly good and I just wish I had the energy these days to make up some of them .
    However I have saved them to my still never ending list of recipes and shared them with my daughter and a friend who I am sure will try them

  2. Caro-Claire, you are so sweet. No guilt! You know, doing these recipes each week helps to keep me creative and cooking now when the daily demands of family are not so pressing. It stretches me so that’s a good thing. I’m glad you share them with your family and friends. That’s cool!

    • Caro-Claire Wiles permalink

      It is a cool and rainy day here today . . Still not very spring like and a good bowl of your soup would go down good right about now!

  3. When I clicked on your blog post today, I knew I would be treated to more than a good broccoli soup recipe. And there is was – a link to the Sorensen Institute for Political Leadership.

    Right now I’m thawing some chili con carne from a restaurant, actually quite good. You may gasp, Melodie. While I feel guilty writing this, it’s cheaper than my usual home-made, which I have done up until Wendy’s ran their chili two for one offer. (But only on Tuesdays.) In a nod to Sandra Lee, it’s semi-homemade though. I add extra kidney beans and tomato sauce. 🙂

    Thanks again for a hearty post.

  4. Fear not, I gasp not. No guilt here. Whatever works–that would tone down the spiciness of Wendy’s which to me can be pretty strong sometimes. I like spicy but it doesn’t always like me. Thanks for chiming in.

  5. karen permalink

    i am looking for this book and saw it mentioned in your blog.
    Marjorie Rohrer
    Country Home Cooking Spiral-bound – 2006
    by Not given (Author),‎ Marjorie Rohrer (Editor) Spiral-bound: 330 pages
    Publisher: Books of Merit (2006)
    ISBN-10: 1602410038
    ISBN-13: 978-1602410039
    I wondered if you have a copy of this book to sell or even photocopies of the pages. I would take it any way I could get it. Thank you, I love your site. Karen

    • No I do not have a copy of that cookbook. I asked at several local outlets, and feel they may be out of print. I will try calling her to find out, I have her phone number, not sure if it has changed. I will let you know if she knows where any of her cookbooks can be found.

      • Karen, I do not want to include the phone number here, but I have a phone number for Marjorie and address where you can write for her cookbook. She sells it from her home for $26 including shipping and she can mail it to you, or if you are in the Shenandoah Valley here, several shops sell the book: Kitchen Wares stores at the Dayton Farmers Market and at Shenandoah Heritage Market, and at Silver Lake Mill in Dayton. Or email me for her address–my email is public at

Trackbacks & Pingbacks

  1. Experimenting with Cheesy-Snow Pea Soup | findingharmonyblog

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Jennifer Murch

Art is the only way to run away without leaving home. -Twyla Tharp

Trisha Faye

Cherishing the Past while Celebrating the Present


To walk or tramp about; to gad, wander. < Old French - trapasser (to trespass).

Tuesdays with Laurie

"Whatever you are not changing, you are choosing." —Laurie Buchanan

Hickory Hill Farm

Blueberries, grapes, vegetables, and more

The Centrality and Supremacy of Jesus Christ

The Website & Blog of David D. Flowers

Cynthia's Communique

Navigating careers, the media and life

the practical mystic

spiritual adventures in the real world

Osheta Moore

Shalom in the City

Shirley Hershey Showalter

writing and reading memoir

Mennonite Girls Can Cook

Harmony, grace and wisdom for family living.

mama congo

Harmony, grace and wisdom for family living.


Harmony, grace and wisdom for family living.

Roadkill Crossing

Writing generated from the rural life

%d bloggers like this: